Why HDR looks washed out, and how to fix it

By TechCompare · Updated · How we check

Washed out HDR is usually SDR content shown in HDR mode, a monitor with too little contrast for HDR, or a setting that caps brightness. Check each one before you blame the screen.

Calculator

HDR Test

Compare two levels. Check whether the two halves look different. If two HDR levels look the same, your setup tops out at or below the lower one.

Run the full screen compare two levels test on TechCompare.

You turn on HDR and the desktop goes gray, colors look flat and blacks look lifted. It's one of the most common HDR complaints, and it usually isn't a fault. The Compare two levels test puts SDR white next to a 1,000 nit patch, so you can see whether your setup shows HDR at all before you start changing settings.

Topic
HDR looks washed out
Washed out picture
Test
Compare two levels
Runs in Chrome, Edge and Safari

How this is calculated

Start with what looks washed out. If it's the desktop and normal apps, that's SDR content shown in HDR mode. Windows fits SDR content into the HDR signal and sets its brightness with the SDR content brightness slider in Settings, System, Display. With the slider low, white looks like a dim gray. Move it until a white page looks the way it did with HDR off.

If HDR movies and games look flat too, look at the screen. HDR needs contrast. An LCD without local dimming has one backlight level for the whole picture, so it has to stay bright for the highlights and lifts every dark part with it. That's why a monitor with a loose black level, like DisplayHDR 400 with its 0.4 nit limit, can look flatter in HDR than in SDR.

Then check the monitor and the cable. Some monitors switch to a separate HDR picture mode with its own brightness and color settings, and eco or power saving modes can cap brightness. A cable or port that can't carry 10-bit color at your resolution and refresh rate can make the PC drop to a lower bit depth or to 4:2:2 color, which can add banding and soften text.

Run the compare test with SDR white on the left and 1,000 nits on the right. If the right patch is clearly brighter, HDR works and the problem is how SDR content is mapped. If both look the same, the screen isn't showing HDR, or SDR white already sits near its peak.

Verdict

Fix it in order: the SDR brightness slider for the desktop, the monitor's HDR mode and power settings, then the cable. If HDR content still looks flat after that, the screen may not have the contrast for it. On a monitor without local dimming, SDR mode can be the better choice for daily use.

More HDR Test scenarios

Frequently asked questions

Why does Windows look gray when I turn on HDR?
Windows shows SDR apps inside the HDR signal, at the level of the SDR content brightness slider in Settings, System, Display. Raise it until white looks right. Some people keep HDR off for the desktop and turn it on for HDR games and video with the Windows key + Alt + B shortcut.
Is washed out HDR a sign of a broken monitor?
Rarely. It's usually SDR content mapped into HDR, a capped brightness setting, or a screen without the contrast for HDR. Check the settings first, then try real HDR video to see what the screen does with it.
Should I use HDR on a DisplayHDR 400 monitor?
Try both with the games and videos you use. Without local dimming, HDR can't make dark parts darker, so the gain is mostly brighter highlights. If HDR looks flatter to you, SDR is the better setting for that screen.